25 years after its debut, "Trading Spaces" exposes the reality of wanting something different out of our homes.

Americans live in cruel homes. People think that owning a home will transform them, but cruel homes make people feel lacking—in security, company, stability, love—even while promising to provide those things, a cycle leading to people feeling hollowed out, scraped to the point of feeling separated from themselves, not feeling real even while being tricked into thinking they’re better off than they are. Cruel homes sell back bits of the feeling of reality that they take away.
This cruelty isn’t uniquely American. It has roots in some of the most fundamental ways that many people think about being in the world. It springs up through the origins of colonialism from the basic promises of Christianity that find a perfect vessel in which to blossom in America. And in reality TV homes, those vessels take some surprising shapes.
Consider Trading Spaces, TLC’s classic home-improvement show, which I took in as a teenager, slack-jawed, on afternoons in the early 2000s. Trading Spaces was a happy show with its bright colors, funky background music, and radiant host, Paige Davis, with her perfect pixie cut. Mostly the show was comforting and fun, not cruel, and it inspired me to paint my bedroom a questionable hot dog combo of mustard yellow and ketchup red. Like millions of others, I was rapt by the show’s positive glow.
Trading Spaces had a pretty simple structure: Every episode, neighbors swapped homes for a couple of days, and with the help of designers and carpenters and $1,000, redid one room in each other’s homes. At the end, the neighbors would go back to their homes, and cameras would watch while they saw their new spaces for the first time.
Some of the renovations were modest—new wall colors, rearranged furniture, and built-in shelving, maybe—and others were more extreme: a basement turned "beach" with real sand covering the floor, an upside-down room with the furniture hanging from the ceiling. Reactions varied from squeals of joy to sobs. The show traveled around the United States, featuring different residents each time and a rotating cast of designers, who became the show’s stars alongside Davis and the carpenters. It premiered in 2000, originally in a 4 p.m. weekday slot, but when it was so successful, executives added a prime-time airing. It became a smash and was nominated for prime-time Emmys in 2002 and 2003. It was light, it was fun, it was breezy. It was a hit.
Ty Pennington, who was one of the show’s on-screen carpenters, became a particularly popular personality on the show, and he tells me about a Beatlemania-esque moment when fans mobbed one of the show’s sets: "I couldn’t even get to my car to get out, and I had to put a trash can over my head, and like, I could smell, like, the garbage juice that was already dripping on me. And I was like, wow, so this is it. This is fame. Like, it smells like garbage."
"It was a movement," Genevieve Gorder, another of the show’s designers, tells me. "It wasn’t just a show."
A living room transformation from TLC’s home reno show Trading Spaces.
Photos © A. Smith & Co. Productions / Courtesy Everett Collection
The show’s host Paige Davis and one of its carpenters, Ty Pennington.
Photo © TLC / Courtesy of Everett Collection
Designers Genevieve Gorder and Douglas Wilson were designers on the show.
Photo © A. Smith & Co. Productions / Courtesy Everett Collection
See the full story on Dwell.com: What America’s Favorite Home Reno Show Reveals Now





















